US Secretary of Commerce Wilbur Ross on Thursday suggested that a new coronavirus outbreak in China might offer an unexpected benefit for the US economy: It could encourage US manufacturers in China to return home.
“I think it will help to accelerate the return of jobs to North America. Some to US, probably some to Mexico as well,” Ross told Fox Business Network.
Novel coronavirus 2019 (2019-nCoV) has paralyzed business in China. The industrial hub of Wuhan and other Chinese cities are on lockdown.
The crisis has also begun to ripple through US companies with operations in China.
Apple Inc CEO Tim Cook has said that the company’s suppliers in China have been forced to delay reopening factories that closed for the Lunar New Year holiday. More than half of Starbucks’ stores in China are now closed. McDonald’s has closed several hundred restaurants in China.
Ross said that he did not “want to talk about a victory lap over a very unfortunate, very malignant disease.”
However, he added: “The fact is, it does give businesses yet another thing to consider when they go through their review of their supply chain.”
Even before the 2019-nCoV outbreak, many US and other foreign companies had been rethinking their presence in China and considering their options for relocating elsewhere, possibly elsewhere in Asia.
That is partly because US President Donald Trump has imposed tariffs on US$360 billion of Chinese imports in a dispute over Beijing’s economic policies, and partly because Chinese labor and other costs have been rising.
However, skeptics doubt that many US companies with deep roots in China might abandon the country purely over the virus.
For one thing, no one knows how long the viral outbreak would last or how much damage it might inflict, and it takes significant time for companies to choose suppliers or locations for their factories.
Rosemary Coates, whose Blue Silk Consulting firm helps companies make such decisions, said it was “ridiculous” to think the viral outbreak would result in a significant return of business to the US.
“You can’t snap your fingers,” she said. “It can take 18 months or two years to find another supplier. It isn’t easy. It’s complicated.”
Wuhan, a center of China’s steel industry, has attracted General Motors Co and many other foreign manufacturing giants.
“You can’t just say General Motors is going to pick up and move away,” Coates said. “They have a manufacturing plant there and expertise there. Their supply chain runs through there.”
US direct investment in China, which includes factories, continued to rise even after the SARS outbreak disrupted the Chinese economy in 2003. Moreover, labor costs would continue to remain far higher in the US than in China and other Asian countries such as Vietnam.
“Companies that are leaving China are not coming to the US,” said Coates, who is also executive director of the Reshoring Institute, a nonprofit that researches issues surrounding corporate decisions on whether to return to the US.
“They’re going to other Asian countries …. If low cost is the only goal, then the US is not the answer,” she said.
After Ross’ comments drew criticism, the commerce department issued a statement: “As Secretary Ross made clear, the first step is to bring the virus under control and help the victims of this disease.”
